Tonic DigitalTonic Digital

  • Home
  • About
  • Specialisations
    • Not-for-Profit
      • Not-For-Profit Marketing
      • Not-For-Profit Grant
      • Social Impact Funds
    • For-Profit
  • Projects
  • Insights
  • Contact
  • Home
  • 2025
  • November

Month: November 2025

Beyond Likes: How Instagram’s 2025 Shift is Rewriting Marketing

Friday, 21 November 2025 by Tonic Digital

Instagram remains one of the world’s most influential digital platforms, with over two billion monthly active users worldwide. Its importance in consumer discovery, brand storytelling, and social commerce remains vital.

At the same time, the features that make Instagram essential are under pressure: engagement rates are dropping, regulatory scrutiny is increasing, and audiences are showing signs of fatigue with overly curated or fake content. Rather than losing its relevance, these shifts are reshaping what success looks like—making adaptability, authenticity, and strategic clarity more vital than ever.

For marketers, this shift presents a dual challenge: how to stand out from the noise while still aligning with evolving user values. However, it also creates opportunities—especially for brands that prioritise authenticity, creative originality, and genuine engagement.

This article examines the key changes shaping Instagram in 2025—focusing on personalisation, content formats, engagement signals, social commerce, and strategic priorities—through a comprehensive analysis designed for modern marketers across APAC.

CONCEPT DEFINITION: INSTAGRAM AS A MULTI-SYSTEM ECOSYSTEM

Instagram in 2025 is no longer a single, unified platform ruled by one algorithm. Instead, it functions as a network of AI-powered systems that influence how content is discovered in different ways.

Q: How has Instagram’s algorithm changed in 2025?

Instagram is no longer a single algorithm serving a uniform audience. It now functions as a network of AI-driven subsystems—each managing a different surface: Feed, Reels, Stories, and Explore. 

These systems prioritise different engagement types and personalise content delivery based on behavioural signals—such as saves, shares, comments, and DMs—rather than relying purely on engagement volume like likes or views.

The shift from a “one algorithm” model to an adaptive AI ecosystem has fundamentally changed how brands should approach content design, distribution, and measurement.

ANALYSING INSTAGRAM’S 2025 EVOLUTION FROM FOUR KEY ANGLES

To understand Instagram’s transformation in 2025, it is essential to examine how various forces—technological, economic, cultural, and regulatory—are coming together to redefine success on the platform. Each perspective provides a different view of the risks and opportunities that marketers face today.

INSTAGRAM’S TECHNOLOGICAL LENS: AI-DRIVEN PERSONALISATION AND CONTROL

Instagram’s modular AI system now ranks content by using multiple models trained on specific signals—like watch time for Reels or comment quality in Stories. These systems analyse who a user typically interacts with, the kinds of content they spend time on, and even the sentiment of previous interactions.

Users are increasingly able to shape what they see. The “Recommendation Reset” feature allows individuals to update their content preferences (Hootsuite, 2024), enabling them to discard outdated algorithmic assumptions. While this gives users more control, it introduces another layer of unpredictability for marketers. Brand strategies now need to focus on maintaining audience relevance rather than chasing quick viral moments.

AI is also transforming creation. The Edits app—Instagram’s new AI-powered content editor—allows video enhancements, background adjustments, and voice layering directly within the platform (EmbedSocial, 2025). This democratises advanced production for small brands while raising the creative standard across the board. It is no longer just about being present—it is about standing out.

Furthermore, predictive analytics integrated into creator tools enables marketers to forecast a post’s potential success before publishing. This helps reduce wasted effort and promotes more strategic content planning.

Q: What kind of content performs best on Instagram in 2025?

A: Content that sparks saves, shares, or replies—like carousels with tips or behind-the-scenes Reels—often performs best. This signals value to Instagram’s algorithm more than likes alone.

INSTAGRAM’S ECONOMIC/BUSINESS LENS: A COMMERCE ENGINE WITH COMPETITIVE ROI

In 2025, Instagram remains a major player in the social commerce space, particularly in mobile-first APAC markets. Brands are increasingly evaluating its role not just as a discovery platform, but as a transactional engine with measurable ROI.

Q: Is Instagram still worth it for brands from a business perspective?

Instagram is now the third most popular global platform for social shopping, with 29% of users making in-app purchases. Conversion rates for ads range between 1% and 3%, and engagement-driven ad campaigns remain competitively priced, with CPCs as low as AUD $0.03–$0.25 (Brandwatch, 2025).

Shoppable content is becoming more seamless. Users can now tap on tagged products in Reels or Stories and complete their purchases without leaving the app. The visual search feature, which allows users to upload a photo to find similar items, integrates discovery with conversion in a single step. In mobile-first markets like Indonesia and Vietnam, this capability supports the growing demand for intuitive, “zero-friction” shopping experiences.

Cost-per-Click (CPCs) as low as AUD $0.03 make Instagram exceptionally cost-effective for regional growth.

Businesses, especially SMEs, benefit from this accessibility. With cost-per-engagement metrics as low as $0.03, Instagram provides a practical entry point for regional brands seeking scalable growth. At the same time, first-party data gathered through Instagram’s native tools—such as in-app browsing history and DM interactions—enables more accurate audience targeting without breaching third-party cookie restrictions.

However, scrutiny is increasing. Regulatory authorities in Singapore and Australia are tightening their focus on influencer transparency and data protection, especially concerning underage users. Brands must ensure compliance with regulations in influencer partnerships, product endorsements, and child-directed advertising to avoid reputational and financial penalties.

INSTAGRAM’S CULTURAL/SOCIAL LENS: DECLINING ENGAGEMENT, RISING DEPTH

Average engagement on Instagram has declined 28% year-over-year, now standing at 0.50% across all industries. However, this headline figure conceals important nuances. Passive engagement—likes and views—is being replaced by signals of deeper involvement, such as saves, meaningful comments, and DMs indicating private sharing.

Instagram’s interface updates mirror this shift. Save buttons are more noticeable, Story polls provide more detailed response choices, and DM features like “Reply Later” and “Save to Folder” promote richer interactions. These subtle changes steer users towards behaviours that match Instagram’s new idea of value.

Definition – DMs: Direct Messages. These private conversations between users are now key indicators of content relevance.

Content formats are also changing. Carousels of up to 20 slides are now used for storytelling, tutorials, and short narratives. These formats work particularly well for sectors like wellness, sustainability, education, and cause-driven marketing. Reels are still important—but top-performing content often blends movement and meaning, mixing quick edits with thoughtful narration or layered audio effects.

In Southeast Asia, regional storytelling has become a significant focus. Brands that incorporate local languages, cultural references, or region-specific humour are experiencing more engagement than generic, global content. Authenticity here means not just being genuine but also being locally relatable.

One Australian brand that exemplifies this approach is Aesop, which has built a values-based Instagram presence rooted in cultural nuance, ethical storytelling, and community-driven engagement. As of September 2025, Aesop maintains over 1.26 million followers, with an engagement rate of 0.16%—considered “average” for its account size but paired with a 0.87% 30-day follower growth rate, which ranks as “excellent” (HypeAuditor, 2025).

INSTAGRAM’S ETHICAL/REGULATORY LENS: TRANSPARENCY, TRUST AND TARGETING

Instagram’s growing influence has led to tighter oversight by regulators and platform operators. New labelling laws for paid content, limits on child-focused advertising, and stricter penalties for misleading influencer campaigns are now standard across many APAC countries.

For example, in Singapore, influencer posts must now disclose any commercial arrangement within the first three seconds of a video or the first line of a caption. In Australia, the ACCC has ramped up its monitoring of social commerce practices, issuing fines to brands that fail to meet disclosure standards.

However, compliance is just one part of building trust. Today’s users—especially Gen Z—place a high value on ethical transparency. They want to know how their data is handled, if reviews are authentic, and whether creators genuinely support what they promote.

This shift creates opportunities for values-driven marketing. Brands that adopt a transparent approach—whether in sourcing, storytelling, or sponsored content—are rewarded with engagement and advocacy. Over time, ethical fluency could become just as vital as creative talent.

STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS: FROM ALGORITHMS TO AUDIENCE RELATIONSHIPS

For marketers and business leaders across the Asia-Pacific region, Instagram in 2025 demands strategic fluency—not just platform familiarity. Success depends on five key imperatives:

  • Create original, conversation-worthy content.
  • Shift from volume to value.
  • Integrate SEO with social media.
  • Redefine success metrics.
  • Design for private sharing and community response.

Ultimately, these shifts require a change in mindset—from targeting audiences in marketing to engaging with communities

KEY TAKEAWAYS

• Instagram in 2025 prioritises depth of engagement — think saves, shares, and DMs.
• Carousels and Reels that tell authentic, useful stories are outperforming static content.
• Ethical transparency and local relevance boost trust and algorithmic favour.
• Regulatory pressure in APAC demands responsible influencer and data practices.
• Strategic fluency, not frequency, is the new metric of success.


References (APA Style)

  • Brandwatch. (2024). 200+ cross-industry social media benchmarks every marketer needs to know. Retrieved from https://www.brandwatch.com/blog/social-media-industry-benchmarks/
  • Brandwatch. (2024). Benchmark: Optimize your social media strategy. Retrieved from https://www.brandwatch.com/products/benchmark/
  • Brandwatch. (2024). The State of Social 2024. Retrieved from https://www.brandwatch.com/reports/state-of-social-2024/
  • HypeAuditor. (2025). 15 Instagram analytics tools to try in 2025. Retrieved from https://hypeauditor.com/blog/15-instagram-analytics-tools-to-try-in-2025/
  • Socialinsider. (2025). Instagram benchmarks by industry. Retrieved from https://www.socialinsider.io/social-media-benchmarks/instagram
  • Socialinsider. (2025). Understanding Instagram’s metrics changes: What’s new in Socialinsider. Retrieved from https://howto.socialinsider.io/en/articles/11184616-understanding-instagram-s-metrics-changes-what-s-new-in-socialinsider
  • Sprout Social. (2025). Social media benchmarks by industry in 2025. Retrieved from https://sproutsocial.com/insights/social-media-benchmarks-by-industry/
  • Brandwatch Help. (2025). Instagram channel metrics in Measure. Retrieved from https://social-media-management-help.brandwatch.com/hc/en-us/articles/22609630468893-Instagram-Channel-Metrics-in-Measure

Read more
  • Published in Data, marketing, SEO
No Comments

Cracker Barrel’s Rebranding Misstep: Navigating the Fragile Line Between Heritage and Modernisation

Thursday, 06 November 2025 by Tonic Digital

In August 2025, Cracker Barrel Old Country Store faced what many analysts are calling the most significant brand crisis in its 56-year history. A bold identity refresh—removing the beloved “Uncle Herschel” figure from its logo and replacing its signature rustic décor with a sleek “modern farmhouse” aesthetic—was intended to attract younger diners and revitalise the brand. Instead, it sparked a viral backlash that erased nearly $100 million in market value within 72 hours (Booth, 2025; Statista, 2025).

Although the company has reversed many of the changes, the damage to consumer trust—and internal confidence—was already done. This was not just a matter of poor design; it was a failure of change governance: modernising a heritage brand without a credible ‘why’, without visible co-creation with loyalists, and without narrative control. The outcome was culture-war framing, a public backtrack to the old logo, and a pause on remodels—decisions that quell outrage but deepen doubts about leadership. 

WHAT HERITAGE BRANDING REALLY MEANS

Cracker Barrel has long embodied a specific kind of Americana nostalgia—complete with checkerboard tablecloths, vintage signage, front porch rocking chairs, and the instantly recognisable “Old Timer” logo. This was not just decor. It was a sensory and emotional environment that customers associated with family road trips, comfort food, and simpler times (Thompson & Tian, 2008).

In brand theory, heritage is not about being old—it is about symbolic continuity. It shows that a brand has origins, values, and a story that lasts across generations (Urde, 2007). When brands modernise, the challenge is: how do you stay relevant without weakening what people love most about you?

Rebranding typically involves updating visual identities, messaging, and customer experiences to align with new strategic objectives (Kotler et al., 2022). However, when emotional capital is deeply embedded in your brand elements, you must proceed with caution. The Cracker Barrel misstep illustrates how heritage can both serve as an advantage and pose a potential hazard.

WHY CRACKER BARREL’S 2025 REBRAND FAILED: A MULTI-LENS ANALYSIS

Q: What caused the backlash to Cracker Barrel’s rebrand?

To understand why the plan unravelled, we must differentiate between symptoms and causes: the design was the initial trigger, but the systems maintained the problem. Four forces—technology, economics, culture, and governance—have shrunk the change window and removed narrative control; we begin with the technological driver.

1. TECHNOLOGICAL LENS: VIRALITY AND THE COLLAPSE OF CONTROL

In the pre-digital age, a brand overhaul might have been received gradually, shaped by press coverage and customer feedback over several months. In 2025, rebranding choices are judged in real-time. Within hours of unveiling its new wordmark, Cracker Barrel became a punchline across TikTok and X (formerly Twitter), with memes mocking the new look as “beige, bland, and betrayal”. 

Cracker Barrel became a punchline across social media within hours of unveiling its new wordmark.

Algorithmic amplification not only speeds up feedback but also strips away context. The reasoning behind the shift in design never truly settled in. What the company presented as modern simplicity was immediately seen as corporate sanitisation.

In the digital age, storytelling must come before design changes. You cannot afford a delay between rollout and explanation. Brands must develop content ecosystems—such as videos, customer journeys, and stakeholder testimonials—that anticipate potential backlash and clearly explain the “why” in emotionally resonant terms.

2. ECONOMIC LENS: EMOTIONAL EQUITY HAS A DOLLAR VALUE

Cracker Barrel’s share price dropped by 7.2% after the backlash, resulting in a US$94 million loss—more than the company’s usual quarterly marketing spend (Statista, 2025). However, the financial strain did not end there. Replacing signs, reprinting menus, updating digital assets, and retraining staff added unplanned costs. Internally, energy was shifted from long-term strategic goals to damage control.

Cracker Barrel lost nearly $100M in market value in just 72 hours.

More importantly, the debacle damaged the long-term brand reputation—a factor that is hard to measure but easy to feel. Analysts observed a notable decline in customer loyalty metrics, particularly among long-standing customers in the American South, the brand’s traditional stronghold.

Emotional brand assets are not just “soft power”—they are financial assets. Like any other asset, they need valuation, protection, and investment. Even well-meaning disruptions can instantly devalue them.

3. CULTURAL LENS: NOSTALGIA AS EMOTIONAL CURRENCY

Cracker Barrel has always sold more than just food—it sells memories. For millions of customers, the “Old Timer” figure and store interiors serve as cultural symbols of tradition, comfort, and Americana. This is especially impactful during times of societal change, when people look for emotional reassurance.

This phenomenon is not unique to Cracker Barrel. In times of uncertainty, brands rooted in cultural nostalgia—such as Tim Tam in Australia or Yakult in Southeast Asia—often experience increased loyalty. As sociologist Svetlana Boym argues, nostalgia acts as “a defence mechanism against the accelerated pace of change” (Holt, 2004).

Removing the Old Timer was more than just a graphic update. To many, it felt like losing an anchor.

The implication for marketers is that nostalgia cannot be “updated” like a font. It must be carefully curated. Modernisation efforts should complement—not erase—the emotional core.

4. ETHICAL AND POLITICAL LENS: THE CULTURE WAR TRAP

What might have remained a design controversy quickly took on political overtones. Conservative commentators accused Cracker Barrel of “erasing Southern heritage,” while progressive critics framed the redesign as pandering to a trend-chasing minimalist aesthetic. The company, unprepared for either narrative, found itself under attack from both sides.

In a polarised media landscape, every aesthetic choice can be ideological. Moreover, brands with culturally specific roots are especially vulnerable.

What this means: Brand decisions today must include political and ethical scenario planning. Even well-intended updates need to be reviewed through a culture-war lens. This is especially relevant in the APAC region, where brands often navigate complex racial, cultural, and colonial histories that vary by market.

Q: HOW SHOULD HERITAGE BRANDS MODERNISE WITHOUT LOSING EMOTIONAL LOYALTY?

Several compounded decisions led to Cracker Barrel’s refresh becoming a reputational crisis.

  • The removal of the logo was total. Instead of a gradual transition, the complete erasure of the Old Timer symbolised a rupture. Customers felt the loss as disorientation rather than a sign of modernisation.
  • Interior redesign co-occurred. The shift to “clean farmhouse” interiors aligned with the logo drop—doubling the visual and emotional impact.
  • Messaging was out of sync. CEO Julie Masino claimed that early feedback was “overwhelmingly positive” (Masino, 2025), but a wave of negative sentiment quickly contradicted this, resulting in mistrust.
  • Testing tools failed to measure emotion. Pre-launch research indicated favourability but failed to capture emotional attachment.
  • Lack of phased roll-out. No pilot markets, no soft launch, no A/B testing. The abrupt, nationwide rebrand left no room for controlled feedback loops.

STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS: A PLAYBOOK FOR HERITAGE BRANDS

Modernisation is unavoidable; the challenge is how to adapt without breaking the bonds that keep a heritage brand meaningful to its loyal followers. The playbook below converts these lessons into practical steps—starting with the first non-negotiable: honour the emotional foundations.

HONOUR EMOTIONAL FOUNDATIONS

Logos, colour schemes, and even scents are not superficial—they are anchors of trust. If change is needed, keep the core intact. Could the Old Timer have been reimagined instead of wiped out?

CONDUCT EMOTIONALLY-DRIVEN RESEARCH

Go beyond “Do you like this?” and ask, “What does this remind you of?” Use qualitative tools—story circles, customer diaries, and co-design sessions—to explore how symbols hold meaning.

PHASE CHANGE STRATEGICALLY

Test new branding in smaller regions or digital-first environments to gauge its effectiveness. Learn from McDonald’s Japan, which piloted retro-modern redesigns in select stores before going national—blending modernity with local nostalgia.

NARRATE THE CHANGE

Visuals alone are not enough. Use storytelling to show how change reflects—not rejects—your values. Explain the shift not just through strategy, but through shared meaning.

PLAN FOR POLITICAL REFRAMING

Even neutral changes can become politicised. Build cross-functional teams—comprising marketing, legal, and risk management—to craft narratives that remain true to the brand’s purpose, not its politics.

REGIONAL RESONANCE: LESSONS FOR APAC BRANDS

While Cracker Barrel’s story is set in the U.S., the lessons resonate across the Asia-Pacific.

In Southeast Asia, family-owned food brands (e.g., BreadTalk or Marigold) navigate similar heritage challenges. A change in packaging or outlet design can risk alienating long-standing customers unless it is clearly linked to cultural continuity.

Across the region, consumer trust is often built over decades. Rapid or opaque changes can undermine this trust faster than any marketing spend can restore.

Cracker Barrel’s crisis is not just a warning—it is a masterclass in what to avoid when updating a legacy brand. In a time of rapid change, the real challenge is not choosing between tradition and modernity—it is blending the two with empathy, intelligence, and strategic discipline.

The brands that will succeed are those that see heritage as an active element, not a limitation. They will invest not only in design systems but also in emotional diagnostics, stakeholder storytelling, and ethical foresight.

For heritage brands across the Asia-Pacific, the way forward is through evolution, not erasure—and by recognising that loyalty is rarely rational. It is emotional. Moreover, in branding, emotions are everything.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

• Heritage branding requires emotional sensitivity and stakeholder alignment.
• Visual updates should be supported by clear storytelling and phased implementation.
• Emotional capital is measurable — and financially consequential.
• Scenario planning must include potential culture-war responses, especially online.
• Brands in APAC must localise heritage storytelling without erasure.


References (APA Style)

  • Booth, M. (2025). Cracker Barrel’s brand redesign triggers $100M backlash. Business Insider.
    Note: Placeholder — verify exact publication and link.
  • Holt, D. (2004). How brands become icons: The principles of cultural branding. Harvard Business Press.
  • Kotler, P., Keller, K. L., & Chernev, A. (2022). Marketing management (16th ed.). Pearson Education.
  • Masino, J. (2025). Cracker Barrel CEO responds to brand backlash. CNBC.
    Note: Placeholder — confirm the date and link to official CNBC interview or coverage.
  • Micu, C. C., & Plummer, J. T. (2010). Measuring emotional meaning in advertising. Journal of Advertising Research, 50(2), 137–153. https://doi.org/10.2501/S0021849910091255
  • Statista. (2025). Cracker Barrel market valuation and brand perception data.
    Note: Placeholder — source data likely from proprietary Statista dashboard or news release.
  • Thompson, C. J., & Tian, K. (2008). Reconstructing the south: How heritage brands articulate cultural myths of the American South. Journal of Consumer Research, 34(3), 350–364. https://doi.org/10.1086/518530
  • Urde, M. (2007). The corporate brand identity matrix. Journal of Brand Management, 15(1), 9–26. https://doi.org/10.1057/palgrave.bm.2550104

Read more
  • Published in Data, marketing, SEO
No Comments

Recent Posts

  • Why Blogging Still Matters for NGOs: The Digital Lifeline Between Mission and Trust

    Blogging remains an NGO’s digital infrastructur...
  • AI’s Adoption in 2026: What This Year Will Demand – and What to Do Now

    AI is no longer a marketing experiment but the ...
  • The Google Antitrust Ruling: What It Means for Business and Users

    The ruling labels Google a monopoly, but real d...
  • When Systems Fail Quietly: Lessons in Nonprofit Leadership

    Quiet system failures hide behind busyness and ...
  • Beyond Likes: How Instagram’s 2025 Shift is Rewriting Marketing

    Instagram in 2025 rewards authenticity and deep...

Recent Comments

    Archives

    • February 2026
    • January 2026
    • December 2025
    • November 2025
    • October 2025
    • September 2025
    • August 2025
    • July 2025
    • June 2025
    • May 2025
    • April 2025
    • March 2025
    • February 2025
    • January 2025
    • December 2024
    • November 2024
    • October 2024
    • September 2024
    • August 2024
    • July 2024
    • June 2024
    • May 2024
    • April 2024
    • March 2024
    • February 2024
    • January 2024
    • December 2023
    • November 2023
    • October 2023
    • September 2023
    • July 2023
    • May 2023
    • April 2023
    • March 2023
    • February 2023
    • January 2023
    • December 2022
    • November 2022
    • October 2022
    • September 2022
    • August 2022
    • July 2022
    • June 2022
    • May 2022
    • April 2022
    • March 2022
    • February 2022
    • January 2022
    • December 2021
    • November 2021
    • October 2021
    • September 2021
    • August 2021
    • July 2021
    • June 2021
    • May 2021
    • April 2021
    • March 2021
    • February 2021
    • March 2020
    • November 2019
    • July 2019
    • June 2019
    • May 2019

    Categories

    • Apps
    • Data
    • Design
    • ethics
    • Google
    • marketing
    • Mobile
    • News
    • NFT
    • Not-For-Profit
    • Psychology
    • SEO
    • Wellbeing
    • Workplace

    Meta

    • Log in
    • Entries feed
    • Comments feed
    • WordPress.org

    OFFICES

    SINGAPORE

    63 Robinson Road, Afro-Asia
    Level 8, 068894

    PERTH

    37 St Georges Tce
    Level 13, 6000

    SOCIAL

    MENU

    ABOUT

    PROJECTS

    INSIGHTS

    CONTACT

    CONTACT

    © 2016 - 2026 | All Rights Reserved
    Privacy & Disclaimer

    TOP