Tonic DigitalTonic Digital

  • Home
  • About
  • Specialisations
    • Not-for-Profit
      • Not-For-Profit Marketing
      • Not-For-Profit Grant
      • Social Impact Funds
    • For-Profit
  • Projects
  • Insights
  • Contact
  • Home
  • 2025
  • September

Month: September 2025

When Purpose Precedes Planning: Why Nonprofits Must Define Their Goals First

Tuesday, 23 September 2025 by Tonic Digital

In recent years, many mental health NGOs across Southeast Asia have been adopting digital transformation strategies to enhance service delivery and broaden their reach. These digitalisation efforts usually involve using the cloud to store counselling records, implementing AI-based triage tools for cases, and creating online training modules to boost volunteer engagement. While these ambitions are noble, the implementation of such strategies can often lead to unforeseen tensions.

Frontline case workers may push back on the new system, claiming that increased administrative workloads and less human nuance in care detracts from their job; volunteers may disengage from their essential roles in the NGO, as a result of failing to establish a more personal bond with the virtual mode of service delivery; and, once-fervent leadership teams begin wondering what the return on their investment might lead to, because they cannot identify measurable outcomes.

More often than not, the struggles stem from a deeper issue: we have prioritised strategy over purpose. In the rush to digitally innovate, the most important question gets lost in all the changes: what are we trying to achieve?

GOALS VS STRATEGY

The non-profit sector often feels pressure to “do more with less.” The constant threat of limited resources endangering survival can foster a culture of busyness, often without clear purpose. As a result, operational plans become driven by strategies, and the line between goals and strategy becomes blurred. This distinction is vital: goals are the organisation’s core reason for existence; strategy explains how, and for what purpose.

In a corporate environment, market competition and shareholder value usually set clear objectives based on financial measures or return on investment indicators. For non-profits, success is less straightforward to quantify. Therefore, there is a greater need to be deliberate when establishing a goal. A strategy without goals is a waste of effort; it focuses on performing purposes rather than achieving them (Ebrahim, 2019).

So, if a significant number of non-profit organisations are still drawn to start with strategy, what is the reason?

IMPACTS OF TECHNOLOGY: TOOLS WITHOUT TARGET

The advances of the digital age are giving organisations unprecedented capacity to scale, gain insights from data, and automate processes. However, they can also tempt organisations to move quickly, often faster than their mission can genuinely progress. Non-profits that rush into strategic action without clearly defining their end goals and focus only on which tools (platforms or outreach methods) to use or how to change risk, unintentionally diverting organisational resources towards features instead of core functionality. 

Implementing a CRM system might enhance tracking engagement with donors; however, if the primary goal is not to attract more donors but to create greater community impact, then this investment could be futile. 

Understanding the important difference between goals and strategies is especially important in multi-cultural Southeast Asian contexts where community expectations, family dynamics, or spiritual beliefs are central. Staff and volunteers might have very personal motivations for their work within an organisation. Without clear organisational goals to guide their motivations, they may face confusion in a vague situation, where many conflicting social narratives are already at play.

A youth mentor in Jakarta might see their commitment as part of their faith; a climate action advocate in Vietnam might view it as a duty to their ancestors. The work is the same, but the meanings could not be more different. Without organisational goals in place, these internal perspectives are not supported. They may lead to dissonance, disconnection, or inaudible disengagement from staff and volunteers, which will impact the strategies used by the non-profit to make an impact.

THE ETHICAL LENS: ACCOUNTABILITY, NOT CLARITY

Nongovernmental organisations operate in the public interest, offering valuable assistance to vulnerable communities. These groups have ethical duties to account not only for how their resources are used but also for what is achieved with them. Ethical accountability involves clear and well-defined goals or objectives set by nonprofit organisations.

When a nonprofit has a plan with strategic activities but lacks clarity about who will be served, what change the organisation aims to achieve, and how and when, a gap emerges where success or failure cannot be adequately assessed. This can ultimately result in a form of tokenism: activities are recorded, outputs are celebrated, and impact is assumed rather than proven (Ebrahim & Rangan, 2014).

Goal-based planning offers clarity (goal) for ethical claims. It provides clarity to stakeholders (clients, funders, staff), not just about what is being achieved but also regarding potential risks.

THE GOVERNANCE LENS: DECISION-MAKING BY DEFAULT

A less noticeable but significant consequence of not having clear goals is the impact on governance. Boards and Leadership Teams tend to process information based on urgency rather than making decisions with a clear direction. The absence of concise, well-defined goals results in limited operational thinking, such as hiring solely around funding cycles, forming partnerships based on opportunity rather than mission fit, and offering services driven by demand instead of actual need.

All of these actions contribute to a governance culture of “accidental strategy” (Bradshaw, 2022). Without a clear purpose as a guiding anchor, even the most well-meaning leadership team can drift towards short-term priorities. Additionally, the checks and balances of accountability often break down. When no single person has ultimate responsibility (and thus no one does), it becomes difficult to hold a governing body accountable.

For governance bodies in Australia and Southeast Asian nations where regulation surrounding nonprofit accountability is tightening, having clearly articulated goals is not just best practice; it is a form of risk management.

THE ECONOMIC LENS: DONOR LOGIC VS. MISSION LOGIC

Many nonprofit organisations have either consciously or unconsciously adapted their objectives to align with their donors’ and funders’ expectations. Since philanthropic capital is linked to metrics, deliverables, and timelines, it can easily override an organisation’s natural tendency to work backwards from the funder’s strategy – asking “What will funders want to fund?” instead of “What is truly important?”.

This is more than just a budgeting challenge; it is a matter of sovereignty. Adjusting the organisation’s objectives to meet external funder criteria – without initially aligning their frameworks with the mission – creates a form of structural dependency. In the short term, such arrangements might satisfy operational needs, but they ultimately compromise the organisation’s identity and mission. Often, as long as funders are supportive, the organisation can reshape itself to fit the funders’ objectives (Frumkin, 2020).

In Southeast Asia, this challenge is significant because many nonprofit organisations operate within a development aid framework where external metrics often determine success. Nonprofits may be assigned indicators such as gender parity, digital equity, or climate mitigation and are not required to define these terms within their own context. In the worst cases, some organisations are agile but fragile regarding their own goals when they align resources to donor priorities.

However, when nonprofits set their goals based on their objectives and mission, funders become stakeholders rather than just applicants. Instead of working against each other, funders can understand their responsibilities to work together towards a shared purpose, as reflected in funding from stakeholder or partner funders. This alignment is beneficial because it deepens the relationship from a simple, linear one-to-one based on mutual accountability.

STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS

The implications for boards, executive teams, and program planners are quite simple:

  1. Begin with questions, not templates: strategy should guide mission — not the reverse.
  1. Define success internally first: if your organisation cannot define what success looks like, then no consultant, software, or grant will help you.
  1. Let your goals anchor your flexibility: paradoxically, we can become more adaptable when we have clear goals. We understand what we can shift and what we cannot shift.
  1. Strategy is a translation: once goals are set, strategy serves as a language to turn the vision into tactics or values into results.
  1. Prioritise participatory goal setting: involve clients, staff, and communities in establishing purpose. This helps build buy-in and ensure alignment from the outset.

In short, goals are not the next step to planning—they are planning.

A DISCIPLINE OF INTENTIONALITY

In the current environment where nonprofits are continually faced with the need to be more effective, transparent, and scalable, there is a tendency to rely on frameworks, plans, and tools. Purpose cannot be reverse-engineered.

Prioritising goals at an initial stage is a management practice grounded in intention. It helps prevent organisational drift, fosters internal cohesion, and turns strategy into action. It also ensures that impact remains through the complexity of being genuine and not just rhetorical.

Those who start with the question “what are we really here to do?” will be best placed to answer the question “are we doing it?”


References (APA Style)

  • Bourne, S. (2023). Digital Strategy for Nonprofits. Oxford Nonprofit Press.
  • Bradshaw, P. (2022). Governance without direction: The risks of accidental strategy. Third Sector Quarterly, 48(2), 193–210.
  • Ebrahim, A. (2019). Measuring Social Change: Performance and Accountability in a Complex World. Stanford University Press.
  • Ebrahim, A., & Rangan, V. K. (2014). What impact? A framework for measuring the scale and scope of social performance. California Management Review, 56(3), 118–141.
  • Frumkin, P. (2020). On Being Nonprofit: A Conceptual and Policy Primer (2nd ed.). Harvard University Press.
  • Lim, H., & Goh, S. (2023). Goal Ambiguity and Burnout in Australia’s Community Sector. Centre for Social Impact, UNSW.

Read more
  • Published in Data, marketing, SEO
No Comments

Unicorn vs Zebra Startups: Balancing Growth and Purpose

Tuesday, 09 September 2025 by Tonic Digital

INTRODUCTION: TWO BEASTS, TWO VISIONS

In the fast-paced world of startups, two compelling archetypes have emerged: the Unicorn and the Zebra. While both promise innovation and growth, they represent fundamentally different visions of success. For entrepreneurs, marketers, and investors—particularly in high-growth, values-driven ecosystems like Australia and Hong Kong—understanding the difference is no longer optional but a strategic necessity.

Unicorns have long shaped the startup story with their billion-dollar valuations and viral growth. However, as disillusionment with unsustainable models increases, an alternative has appeared: Zebra, a profitable and purpose-driven company growing with integrity rather than speed.

This article explores the key differences between these models, why the divergence matters, and how Zebra thinking is gaining prominence in Asia’s innovation economies.

WHAT ARE UNICORNS AND ZEBRAS?

UNICORNS

A term coined by venture capitalist Aileen Lee in 2013, it refers to privately owned startups valued at over $1 billion. Their growth is usually driven by substantial venture capital funding and a strong drive for rapid expansion. Their aim? To dominate markets, achieve quick exits through Initial Public Offerings (IPOs) or acquisitions, and deliver maximum returns for early investors.

ZEBRAS

Introduced in 2017 by a group of female founders, Zebras represent a conscious shift away from the Unicorn ethos. They are “black and white”—both profitable and purposeful. These companies address genuine issues, often at the crossroads of social and economic needs, and focus on sustainability, collaboration, and stakeholder engagement.

THE UNICORN PLAYBOOK: SPEED, SCALE, AND DISRUPTION

Unicorns have become symbols of ambition. Their defining traits include:

  1. Exponential Growth: Rapid scaling and industry disruption through technology or innovative business models.
  2. Heavy reliance on venture capital: Success depends on securing multiple investment rounds, often at the expense of profitability.
  3. Winner-Takes-All Mentality: Market share dominates, even if it involves burning cash or sidelining ethics.
  4. Valuation Over Revenue: Valuations typically indicate potential instead of established business fundamentals.
  5. Exit-Oriented: The main aim is a high-stakes exit that benefits investors more than the long-term stability of the ecosystem.

Unicorns represent dynamic environments for marketers where metrics like viral growth, complex user acquisition, and market visibility are key priorities.

THE ZEBRA ALTERNATIVE: SUSTAINABILITY MEETS PURPOSE

Zebras challenge the notion that bigger is always better. Their main characteristics are:

  1. Dual Bottom Line: Profitability is attained alongside a social or environmental mission 
  2. Steady Growth: Business development aligns with operational maturity and has a long-term impact.
  3. Alternative Capital: Zebras frequently bootstrap or collaborate with impact investors, prioritising alignment over rapid growth.
  4. Ethical Operations: Promoting inclusive leadership, maintaining ethical supply chains, and prioritising collaboration over competition.
  5. Embedded Impact: Zebras reinvest in the communities they serve, often putting profits back into local initiatives.

Authenticity remains the cornerstone of marketing Zebra ventures. Campaigns revolve around storytelling, community, and communicated impact.

WHY THE DIFFERENCE MATTERS

BUSINESS MODEL RESILIENCE

Unicorns are built for speed but often lack the structural strength to survive storms. Cases like WeWork and Theranos show the dangers of inflated valuations and poor governance. Zebras are naturally more resilient and rooted in real revenue and mission integrity.

SOCIETAL ALIGNMENT

While Unicorns often concentrate value and risk, leading to social harm, Zebras are closely connected to real-world issues—education, climate, and inequality. This focus on societal relevance is a strength, not a sacrifice, in a region as diverse and developmentally complex as Asia.

ORGANISATIONAL HEALTH

The “grow or die” culture of Unicorns often results in founder burnout and toxic workplaces. On the other hand, Zebra companies tend to focus on wellness, values-led leadership, and team cohesion—a shift especially relevant in the post-pandemic period.

CAPITAL MODELS

Venture capital mainly targets quick growth and short-term investment returns. Zebra-friendly models—such as revenue-based financing or community co-ops—support more patient and meaningful growth. This also opens doors for diverse founders who might not fit the traditional venture capital mould.

THE ASIAN CONTEXT: WHY ZEBRAS BELONG

Although originally coined in the West, Zebra’s values align with many Asian cultural and economic norms.:

  1. Collectivism over Individualism: Many Asian cultures prioritise community well-being over personal gain, fitting well with a Zebra-style business.
  2. Long-term stewardship is a hallmark of family-run businesses and generational values across Asia. Zebras’ sustainable ethos resonates strongly in this context.
  3. Government alignment: Through active public-private partnerships (e.g., Singapore’s Smart Nation), startups often function within system-oriented frameworks—an ideal environment for Zebras.

This convergence indicates that Asia may adopt and evolve the Zebra model substantially and regionally uniquely.

CASE STUDIES: SINGAPORE AND HONG KONG

SINGAPORE: ECOSYSTEM FOR ETHICAL GROWTH

Singapore’s government is increasingly favouring sustainable, impact-driven enterprises. Supportive policies around ESG, social finance, and green innovation create a fertile ground for Zebras.

  1. Stability and Diversification: Zebra companies promote economic resilience by expanding the startup ecosystem beyond major tech firms.
  2. Impact-Driven Investment: A growing interest in measurable social benefits attracts capital outside traditional VC channels (Happiness at Work Experience).

HONG KONG: A SHIFT TOWARDS PURPOSE

Though traditionally recognised for high finance and rapid-growth ventures, Hong Kong is beginning to support startups focusing on social innovation, environmental health, and public resilience.

  1. Local Impact, Long-Term Value: Zebras foster lasting relationships with customers and staff by meeting real needs.
  2. Funding Diversity: Impact bonds, revenue-based models, and community investment promote a more inclusive environment.

ZEBRAS STARTUPS IN ACTION

Three standout examples—Bettr Barista, Green Monday, and Wateroam—demonstrate what this looks like in practice.

BETTR BARISTA (SINGAPORE)

Founded in 2011, Bettr Barista is a certified B-Corporation and social enterprise that uses coffee to uplift marginalised communities. Its coffee academy trains at-risk women and youth in barista skills and emotional development, creating long-term employment pathways. Over the years, it has grown into one of Singapore’s most respected specialty coffee brands, combining retail, training, and impact. Bettr avoids the hypergrowth tactics typical of startups; instead, its expansion is grounded in community need and quality delivery. Investors and partners—including socially aligned funds—support its mission, proving that profitability and purpose coexist. The measure of success is not just cups sold but lives changed.

GREEN MONDAY (HONG KONG)

Launched in 2012 by David Yeung, began as a movement to promote plant-based eating. It has since evolved into a powerful social enterprise platform blending business with advocacy. Its profit-generating arms include Green Common (plant-based groceries and restaurants) and OmniFoods (meat alternatives), while its foundation focuses on education and climate initiatives. Despite securing substantial funding, including AU$70 million in 2020, Green Monday stays true to its mission. Every product launch or new outlet supports its environmental aims. Collaborating with schools and businesses helps shift behaviours and markets, with success measured by carbon emissions saved and habits changed, rather than just revenue growth.

WATEROAM (SINGAPORE)

Founded in 2014, Wateroam develops portable water filtration systems for rural and disaster-affected areas. It collaborates with NGOs and humanitarian organisations to provide clean water to underprivileged communities, aiming to reach 30 million people by 2030. Wateroam exemplifies the zebra model by merging technical innovation with a strong social commitment. Its business model ensures sustainability: filtration units are sold at affordable prices, and profits are reinvested to extend reach and improve effectiveness. Instead of chasing trendy pivots or wealthy markets, Wateroam expands only when it benefits more people by giving them access to safe water. Impact is central, not secondary, to its strategy.

These startups demonstrate how zebra companies grow differently. Bettr Barista expands its training as demand for skilled baristas increases. Green Monday aligns its growth with education to maintain credibility. Wateroam innovates to reach those most in need. All three are profitable and scalable, yet they resist the temptation to grow at any cost. In doing so, they exemplify a new kind of entrepreneurship: success is measured by the depth of impact, not just the speed of scale.

STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS FOR MARKETERS AND FOUNDERS

The emergence of Zebra startups does not critique Unicorns but signifies a necessary shift. Both models play vital roles in ecosystems like Singapore and Hong Kong, where innovation links with policy, identity, and sustainability. 

  1. For Unicorns: Marketers must excel in fiercely competitive, data-rich environments, quickly generate broad awareness, and optimise for substantial growth.
  2. For Zebras: Marketers become storytellers and bridge-builders, crafting narratives that connect values, foster community, and demonstrate tangible impact.

For founders, the key question shifts from “How fast can we grow?” to “What are we growing—and for whom?”

CONCLUSION: THE FUTURE BELONGS TO BOTH

A single model does not dominate a vibrant startup scene but embraces diversity. Unicorns challenge what is achievable, while zebras remind us of what truly matters. Together, they create a lively tension—innovation with integrity and speed balanced by substance.

In Asia, where the future is being shaped through social innovation, digital transformation, and cultural renewal, Zebras are ready to survive and prosper. They are redefining what success means—not by escaping gravity, but by building companies that stand the test of time.

The choice is not simple for the next generation of entrepreneurs in Singapore, Hong Kong, and beyond. The call is to build boldly—but with eyes wide open, feet firmly grounded, and values intact.

Read more
  • Published in Data, marketing, SEO
No Comments

Recent Posts

  • Why Blogging Still Matters for NGOs: The Digital Lifeline Between Mission and Trust

    Blogging remains an NGO’s digital infrastructur...
  • AI’s Adoption in 2026: What This Year Will Demand – and What to Do Now

    AI is no longer a marketing experiment but the ...
  • The Google Antitrust Ruling: What It Means for Business and Users

    The ruling labels Google a monopoly, but real d...
  • When Systems Fail Quietly: Lessons in Nonprofit Leadership

    Quiet system failures hide behind busyness and ...
  • Beyond Likes: How Instagram’s 2025 Shift is Rewriting Marketing

    Instagram in 2025 rewards authenticity and deep...

Recent Comments

    Archives

    • February 2026
    • January 2026
    • December 2025
    • November 2025
    • October 2025
    • September 2025
    • August 2025
    • July 2025
    • June 2025
    • May 2025
    • April 2025
    • March 2025
    • February 2025
    • January 2025
    • December 2024
    • November 2024
    • October 2024
    • September 2024
    • August 2024
    • July 2024
    • June 2024
    • May 2024
    • April 2024
    • March 2024
    • February 2024
    • January 2024
    • December 2023
    • November 2023
    • October 2023
    • September 2023
    • July 2023
    • May 2023
    • April 2023
    • March 2023
    • February 2023
    • January 2023
    • December 2022
    • November 2022
    • October 2022
    • September 2022
    • August 2022
    • July 2022
    • June 2022
    • May 2022
    • April 2022
    • March 2022
    • February 2022
    • January 2022
    • December 2021
    • November 2021
    • October 2021
    • September 2021
    • August 2021
    • July 2021
    • June 2021
    • May 2021
    • April 2021
    • March 2021
    • February 2021
    • March 2020
    • November 2019
    • July 2019
    • June 2019
    • May 2019

    Categories

    • Apps
    • Data
    • Design
    • ethics
    • Google
    • marketing
    • Mobile
    • News
    • NFT
    • Not-For-Profit
    • Psychology
    • SEO
    • Wellbeing
    • Workplace

    Meta

    • Log in
    • Entries feed
    • Comments feed
    • WordPress.org

    OFFICES

    SINGAPORE

    63 Robinson Road, Afro-Asia
    Level 8, 068894

    PERTH

    37 St Georges Tce
    Level 13, 6000

    SOCIAL

    MENU

    ABOUT

    PROJECTS

    INSIGHTS

    CONTACT

    CONTACT

    © 2016 - 2026 | All Rights Reserved
    Privacy & Disclaimer

    TOP